I voted for Bachir Gemayel, bass the only other charismatic leader in the selection is Hassan Nassrallah (mich add bachir that's for sure bass he is charismatic).
Michel Aoun is only charismatic for me when he says: "Ya cha3ba loubnane l 3azim" and he's not charismatic at all when he looses his temper.
Rafic Hariri is not Charismatic imo.
For me a charismatic leader is a leader that even if you hate him, when you start listening to him you can't stop (even your saying 3 mssabeit/sec to him).
the Charisma "augmente" when he has the ability to speek balla 3ayit while still forcing you to listen to him, ba3dena fi 7araket wejo w iddeh w chaklo bi assro, w Bach got all of those, mitlo ma khéli2 w ma ra7 yékhla2!
I have some videos of him talking to foreign press fi ma7aleit bi satil even if he's talking English or French.