Do You think that Hezbollah Will Submit the Arms??

[Jean]

the war seems that will end very soon, and many problematics, old and new, will face lebanon, including Hezbollah Arms!
So do you think that HA will submit the arms? and why ?

(plz let your votes be based on a political analyse, not on a wishes and feelings)

[xcoder]

Yes, for the following reasons:
-Hezbollah never turned their arms to the inside.
-Hezbollah was created because of the israeli occupation and its main goal is to free the lebanese land.
-Lebanese will find a solution to merge the hizb arms with the lebanese army and that's what i prersonaly think.
-Hezbollah won't destroy its herotic picture by attacking any lebanese and it's not of their principles.
-They have proved they are strong enough to protect the south at least but of course it doesn't mean the lebanese army should not be the first and the last decision of any military actions.

i hope i answered the question.

[JouJoulika]

no because of the following reasons :
1- if we can consider now that HA won the war because the Israeli army couldn't defeat them then the winner can't submit the arms cause then he would feel that he failed
2- this winning will force him to be attached more to his weapon
3- the strategy is not to merge HA in the Lebanese army but to organize the HA military so it won't bi a submit
4- we don't know when Israel will attack next time and we need HA to help us resist against the attack because he's our only hope I mean the last attack was already organized by Israel and if HA wasn't prepared (after his operation) God knows where we could have ended up
5-today: 12.30: ليفني لا يستطيع جيش في العالم ان يجرد حزب الله من سلاحه
so this proves that HA will not submit his weapon only it will be organized with the strategy which will take for about ten years ta tetnaffaz kell L strategy
another thing the government now is in the hand of the siniyye right? and always always remember that the shi3as will never give his weapon to the siniyye

[General]

Hezbollah cares about LEBANON more than many others in here... when the UNIFIL arrives to the south, and the Lebanese Army's in the south, the israeli danger reduces to 0... the thing that will lead to a disarmement by Hezbollah...

Suggestion: I wish all HA fighters join the Lebanese Army and form a special group/force in it...

[enigma]

Yes, but not so soon for the following reasons:
- I don't think that Hezbollah will be disarmed before the Palestinians so we have to wait for a real strong Lebanese government to take such an important decision.
- Also we have to wait a month to see a final delineation of the international borders of Lebanon, especially in those areas where the border is disputed or uncertain, including by dealing with the Shebaa farms area
- And after this month all the Lebanese will celebrate the win and forget about the arms.
- hizbollah will be disarmed when he starts to lose his supporters and when Israel is totally out of Lebanon
so after this war if we can form a strong government I think that Hezbollah will be disarmed by next spring.

[KeXasthur]

Originally Posted by joujoulika

no because of the following reasons :
1- if we can consider now that HA won the war because the Israeli army couldn't defeat them then the winner can't submit the arms cause then he would feel that he failed
2- this winning will force him to be attached more to his weapon
3- the strategy is not to merge HA in the Lebanese army but to organize the HA military so it won't bi a submit
4- we don't know when Israel will attack next time and we need HA to help us resist against the attack because he's our only hope I mean the last attack was already organized by Israel and if HA wasn't prepared (after his operation) God knows where we could have ended up
5-today: 12.30: ليفني لا يستطيع جيش في العالم ان يجرد حزب الله من سلاحه
so this proves that HA will not submit his weapon only it will be organized with the strategy which will take for about ten years ta tetnaffaz kell L strategy
another thing the government now is in the hand of the siniyye right? and always always remember that the shi3as will never give his weapon to the siniyye

Wait...Livni said by Force, and by army NO ONE CAN destroy and disarm hezbollah . and that is what we saw, this has nothing to do with whether hezbollah can be disarmed by negotiations..

I think hezbollah proved that his weapons is an internal issue that israel has no F**cken right to interfere in.

Thats why they lost and hezbollah won.

[Patriotic]

Originally Posted by xcoder

Yes, for the following reasons:

Originally Posted by xcoder

1-Hezbollah never turned their arms to the inside.
2 -Hezbollah was created because of the israeli occupation and its main goal is to free the lebanese land.
3 -Lebanese will find a solution to merge the hizb arms with the lebanese army and that's what i prersonaly think.
4 -Hezbollah won't destroy its herotic picture by attacking any lebanese and it's not of their principles.
5 -They have proved they are strong enough to protect the south at least but of course it doesn't mean the lebanese army should not be the first and the last decision of any military actions.

i hope i answered the question.

Hello
Nice reply Dan.

As for (1), just for informations, Hizbollah had a war for about two years agaisnt Amal. If we consider Hizbollah a Lebanese militia, so we have to say that yes he did join intertnal wars. Plus, we all remember then during the Liberation war against the syrian occupation, Hizbollah formed a league with the palestinians militias (fate7), and PSP (joumblat) and Amal and the communist party and fight against the Lebanese Army. So it is not a simple internal war, but against the GOVERNMENT. More to come, if we go down in front of the ESKWA building, you can find a tant, it belongs to the mothers and families of the Lebanese In Syrian Prisons, and ask A HUGE NUMBER OF THEM, Who sent your son to the syrian prison? The answer will be HIZBOLLAH.

So based to this 3 sequences, we can say that Hizbollah joine civil and internal warZ.

2) If Hizbollah was made to fight the Israelis occupation, can you please explain to me the meaning of their flag? What does the Yellow color mean? What does the Green color mean? What does the weapon mean? And finally what does the sentence الثورة الاسلامية في لبنان mean? What's the islamic revolution? What does Islamic means?
As for the land, how could it be a resistance and they agreed to have a palestinian occupation, and they collaborate agaisnt Lebanon with the Syrian occupation.

3) Based to 2), i don't think so.

4) Does he have an Herotic picture? Where? Show it to me and to the Lebanese people.

5) As said in another thread,i was not expecting from Hezbollah to invade Israel, but at least as he used to say : to ban israel to enter Lebanon, but they did not. What a defence strategy. I do not to throw Katyoucha and Raad and Khaybar and etc, to Haifa, but i want to have a safe free Lebanon.

As for the tanks, if you are based to the Manar, New Tv, Arabiyah or Al Jazeera news, we could say that Hizbollah is not in Haifa and Hassan Nassrallah is living in the middle of Tel Aviv and there is no more existance to the Israelis army or people.

[patriotic_girl]

I replied by no unfortunately..
The resistance did a great job but It's time we build our country away from wars. We have to start building our army, and have a government that takes responsibilty for its actions.

But I don't see this coming, on one side I blame Hezballa, and on the other side I blame the government , and its always that we are the victims.

[KeXasthur]

^^^ A Nice answer....

At least, appropriate after this war.

[moetart]

nassrallah said he will
so 99% he will