Federalism

[El-Meghwar]

Originally Posted by Bachir-Gemayel

plus most of you are against Federalism becuase Samir Geagea tara7 l fekra, i bet if GMA did, you would accept it 100% and so do your allies.

LOL , nice analyse .
lei asslan do u think that Geagea knows what fideralism is ?? he asked for it just because he was dreaming of dominating the christian area and ruling it,of course because ruling Lebanon is an impossible dream for a person hated by 90% of the population ... so he said maybe i can dominate the christian area by force,and he used the idea about "fideralism" as a cover for his ambition .

back to the subject,Lebanon is too small to be divided,there is no logical reason to switch our regime to a fideral one.The multiplicity of religions in Lebanon is not a cause !!
the Lebanese people can be united whatever was their religions,we just need patriotic and secular leaders who doesent have this sick mentality about " Oh he's a muslim !" ..or "Oh he's christian !".
the Lebanese people (muslims,druzes,christians,jews etc..) are One people and can live in peace and unity... we just need to get rid of those sick "leaders" who imposed themselves by force on their social environment.

[BG]

by the way, who told you that federalism = to2sim ?

[General]

Originally Posted by Bachir-Gemayel

by the way, who told you that federalism = to2sim ?

because you only see federalism from the swiss and the American perspective

but if you take a closer look at the Lebanese heterogeneity (of religions, cultures, sub-cultures, languages, origins, beliefs etc...) you'll change what's in your mind... and it's a pure division...

Federalism in Lebanon is an absolute failure

1) 17 religions living together in the 10452 km2
2) too many cultures
3) too many nationalities (Lebanese, Armenians, Kurds, Syrians, Palestinians...)

Federalism is the last resort of Tawteen, it'll keep the Palestinians in Lebanon for the end of time and they'll never go back home + they'll become Lebanese from a Lebanese state...

overall, it can't be done in Lebanon, and if it is done, good bye lebanon

[BG]

Originally Posted by General Rami

because you only see federalism from the swiss and the American perspective

but if you take a closer look at the Lebanese heterogeneity (of religions, cultures, sub-cultures, languages, origins, beliefs etc...) you'll change what's in your mind... and it's a pure division...

Federalism in Lebanon is an absolute failure

1) 17 religions living together in the 10452 km2
2) too many cultures
3) too many nationalities (Lebanese, Armenians, Kurds, Syrians, Palestinians...)

Federalism is the last resort of Tawteen, it'll keep the Palestinians in Lebanon for the end of time and they'll never go back home + they'll become Lebanese from a Lebanese state...

overall, it can't be done in Lebanon, and if it is done, good bye lebanon

So if you are going to take from your prospective, then we already have federalism:

- The State of DJ (dahye jnoubiyyeh)
- South
- Bourj hammoud (Armenians)
- Tarick Jdideh
and so and so .... all are classified regions!

This Federalism is from different prospective, wich is the Swiss , or American or whatever.

[General]

Originally Posted by Bachir-Gemayel

So if you are going to take from your prospective, then we already have federalism:

- The State of DJ (dahye jnoubiyyeh)
- South
- Bourj hammoud (Armenians)
- Tarick Jdideh
and so and so .... all are classified regions!

This Federalism is from different prospective, wich is the Swiss , or American or whatever.

lah

I live in jbeil, bas brou7 bsajjel el siyyara bel nef3a

figure the rest...

we don't have federalism my friend, we have A ZOO living in that's it...

[xcoder]

Originally Posted by Bachir-Gemayel

plus most of you are against Federalism becuase Samir Geagea tara7 l fekra, i bet if GMA did, you would accept it 100% and so do your allies.

I'll be the frist to leave FPM if this happens, however i thought u were 10452.
as for samir geagea. federalism doesn't mean men l damour lal madfoun does it?

[BG]

Originally Posted by xcoder

federalism doesn't mean men l damour lal madfoun does it?

no and try to read a little bit

[xcoder]

Originally Posted by Bachir-Gemayel

no and try to read a little bit

i know what it means, when u want federalism based on religions it's to2sim. see?
The solution for lebanon is Decentralization not federalism.

[El-Meghwar]

Originally Posted by Bachir-Gemayel

by the way, who told you that federalism = to2sim ?

so can u enlighten me and tell me what's Federalism ?!

النظام الفيدرالي أحد أنظمة الدول المركبّة
أمّا النظام اللبناني الحالي فهو نظام برلماني الذي هو أحد الأنظمة
في الدول البسيطة

as "xcoder" said the solution in Lebanon is Decentralization not federalism.

[BG]

please meghwar , take your time reading

http://vcoderz.com/forum/showpost.ph...6&postcount=19