A question...

[Choukou]

Hello everyone,

something came up to my mind, HA is a Lebanese party we all agree on that but there is something that is confusing me and I'm sure if u think about it u'll get confused too! SHN is known the " Amin 3am" of HA! w metel ma bta3erfo kel 7ezeb 2elo haykaliye. ya3ne ra2is,Amin 3am,na2ib amin 3am.....

My question is if SHN is the amin 3am, who's the president of HA? it cannot be SH because he is the amin 3am! there is someone higher than him in the party! Who is he? and why they never mentioned him? one more question is the president Lebanese? I'm sure u guys don't know the answers but have u ever thought about it?

[mr_j]

I don't think fi ra2is for HA
HA wouldn't place all its power and integrity on one man
I also highly doubt SHN writes his own speeches or at least I highly doubt that his speech is not revised by at least a comitee of 10 to 15 people
same in military strategy, you think SHN just came out and asked HA to kidnap the prisonners? surely there were planners and a voting happened and etc... there is no one president for HA
the sayyed is the public figure that addresses the public, he is not the only mind in there, I won't be surprised if there are some things he himself does not know about

[Sogelec]

Originally Posted by Choukou

Hello everyone,

something came up to my mind, HA is a Lebanese party we all agree on that but there is something that is confusing me and I'm sure if u think about it u'll get confused too! SHN is known the " Amin 3am" of HA! w metel ma bta3erfo kel 7ezeb 2elo haykaliye. ya3ne ra2is,Amin 3am,na2ib amin 3am.....

My question is if SHN is the amin 3am, who's the president of HA? it cannot be SH because he is the amin 3am! there is someone higher than him in the party! Who is he? and why they never mentioned him? one more question is the president Lebanese? I'm sure u guys don't know the answers but have u ever thought about it?

Nope Choukou..U r mistaken in 1 of ur pts,
What U said eno Kel 7ezeb elo haykaleye is RIGHT, But Who Said that all parties Have the Same Haykaleye?
Kataeb Have a President, But Meen howe l Ameen l 3am?
Who is the president of (Shoyo3e) Party?while they have a Ameen 3am
l Ouwat l Lebneney 3endon Hay2a Tanfezeye...
and the list continues...so DW, The Head of HA is SHN (Allah Ye7me)
For You to Understand HA, HA HEAD is like a board of Directors (Around 8 or 10)..1 or 2 of them are known (Shey5 Moh'd Yazbek), and the others are not even seen or known, and SHN is like da CEO...Clear?

[Choukou]

Originally Posted by Sogelec

Nope Bro..U r mistaken in 1 of ur pts,
What U said eno Kel 7ezeb elo haykaleye is RIGHT, But Who Said that all parties Have the Same Haykaleye?
Kataeb Have a President, But Meen howe l Ameen l 3am?
Who is the president of (Shoyo3e) Party?while they have a Ameen 3am
l Ouwat l Lebneney 3endon Hay2a Tanfezeye...
and the list continues...so DW, The Head of HA is SHN (Allah Ye7me)
For You to Understand HA, HA HEAD is like a board of Directors (Around 8 or 10)..1 or 2 of them are known (Shey5 Moh'd Yazbek), and the others are not even seen or known, and SHN is like da CEO...Clear?

it doesn't make sense ok ra7 salim jadalan ma3ak SHN is the President like u said laken why they call him Amin 3am? fi chi mech mazbout! when in the party u have Amin 3am that's mean u have a president!

[Sogelec]

Originally Posted by Choukou

it doesn't make sense ok ra7 salim jadalan ma3ak SHN is the President like u said laken why they call him Amin 3am? fi chi mech mazbout! when in the party u have Amin 3am that's mean u have a president!

Who is the President of Shoyo3i Party?
Who is the President of Tashnagh Party?

[Sheriff Ice]

Originally Posted by Choukou

Hello everyone,

something came up to my mind, HA is a Lebanese party we all agree on that but there is something that is confusing me and I'm sure if u think about it u'll get confused too! SHN is known the " Amin 3am" of HA! w metel ma bta3erfo kel 7ezeb 2elo haykaliye. ya3ne ra2is,Amin 3am,na2ib amin 3am.....

My question is if SHN is the amin 3am, who's the president of HA? it cannot be SH because he is the amin 3am! there is someone higher than him in the party! Who is he? and why they never mentioned him? one more question is the president Lebanese? I'm sure u guys don't know the answers but have u ever thought about it?

Choukou each party has a different structure,

FPM has a structure different tha LF
Kataeb has a structure different than Shuyu3i

It depends on the internal bylaws of the party

[Kain]

Originally Posted by Choukou

it doesn't make sense ok ra7 salim jadalan ma3ak SHN is the President like u said laken why they call him Amin 3am? fi chi mech mazbout! when in the party u have Amin 3am that's mean u have a president!

1- Sayyed Hassan is...as Sogelec put it..the CEO of HA

2- All decisions in HA are taken by a meeting of all the heads of the party,and Majles shoura Hezbollah....it's called Majles l shoura because the decisions are taken by shoura ya3ne byetshewaro Which means that SHN cannot take decisions alone.

I don't understand what's so confusing...consider el ameen l 3am to be the equivalent of president in other parties...bas ma3 ekhtilef bel haykaliyye.

[Choukou]

Originally Posted by Sogelec

Who is the President of Shoyo3i Party?
Who is the President of Tashnagh Party?

ya 3ayne 3lek! that's my question?! Tashnag also have an Amin 3am. kamenThere should be a president! chou party bala president!

[Choukou]

There is tashnag in London,in US, in Iran,in Australia,in Lebanon,syria.... and they all have amine 3am w 3ando mas2oul either in Armenia or somewhere else.

same with HA!

[Sheriff Ice]

Originally Posted by Choukou

it doesn't make sense ok ra7 salim jadalan ma3ak SHN is the President like u said laken why they call him Amin 3am? fi chi mech mazbout! when in the party u have Amin 3am that's mean u have a president!

Choukou it is just the naming that is different,

HA has a Council this is why the president is called Amin Aam
Other parties follow one man party this is why is called president like the republic