Bachir Gemayel vs Palestinians

[TAREK®]

Did BG have the right to do what he did to the palestinians, in one hand the palestinians killed a lot of christians for no reason at all, but on the other hand BG killed a lot of Palestinians who were innocent in a ruthless way... what do u think?

[SysTaMatIcS]

sho zakkarak b hal mawdoo3 , this thread will reach several pages and in the end the admins will close it due to the heat in it like every thread about BG

[JouJoulika]

مش رح نخلص؟؟؟؟؟

[Sheriff Ice]

Originally Posted by TAREK®

Did BG have the right to do what he did to the palestinians, in one hand the palestinians killed a lot of christians for no reason at all, but on the other hand BG killed a lot of Palestinians who were innocent in a ruthless way... what do u think?

Tarek this topic is very controversial, what both side did is unacceptable at any level, killing is refused whom ever do it.
On the other side, if you look at BG/LF/Christians they were afraid about their existence, which is the same fears of HA at the moment or earlier before the MOU.

it was a chaotic war at that time, i am not defending BG or anyone i dont like him or like the way he acted.

But when ur existence is in danger, you have the right to defend yourself.
When Palestinians came to Lebanon The lebanese people was the only on who opened his doors for the refugees, at that time the Palestinians should have respected the lebanese people and shouldn't have interfered in the internal politics .

There are to many things to explain but this is how i see it.

[ibllise]

Did BG have the right to do what he did to the palestinians,

he was defending his country..
a mean to an end!

what do u think?

[SysTaMatIcS]

Originally Posted by ibllise

he was defending his country..
a mean to an end!

what do u think?

that doesnt justify the killing of innocent civilians in anyway.

[ibllise]

what civilians ur talking about??

massacres u mean?
there was no order to kill any civilian in any history book..

what ppl used to do in war is not related in anyway to the CQ!
what does it have to do with bachir if someone goes and start cutting the ears of ppl?

[IM@D]

If there was no Bachir Gemayyel you would have now:
_7ayfa TV rather than OTV
_ Afran Abou 3ammar rather than Yanni
_ Cap sur 3arafat rather than Cap Sur Ville

The one that knows the geographical place of these things will understand what I am saying

[SysTaMatIcS]

Originally Posted by ibllise

what civilians ur talking about??

massacres u mean?
there was no order to kill any civilian in any history book..

what ppl used to do in war is not related in anyway to the CQ!
what does it have to do with bachir if someone goes and start cutting the ears of ppl?

oh common , your the only BG fanatic i see in years that denies the massacres , they all agree they happened and they defend BG for them , saying they were necessary and bla bla

[ibllise]

i didnt give excuses for the massacres or said that were necessary..

i just said that whatever happened in any of them wasnt planned to be like that..

Sabra and Chatila for example!